World Cup fever, and the racial harmony it has inspired in her
country, is something Caroline Motholo has experienced only from
On the periphery of her more-than-full life – she runs a
day-care center catering mostly to orphans whose parents have died
of AIDS – she has seen the images: white and black South Africans
side by side in the stadiums and fan parks, cheering together for
their national team before its ouster, sharing pride that their
once-shunned homeland is host for such a grand event.
Yet virtually everyone she sees in Vosloorus, a dusty township
of 150,000 people on the outskirts of Johannesburg, is black. The
community has vast tracts of small homes, and a jobless rate above
40 percent. Few whites ever set foot in it.
”I wish that spirit would stay,” Motholo said, sounding
hopeful but not confident that the World Cup euphoria will live
She’s lived in Vosloorus for 16 years, but said she knows no
white people from Boksburg, the nearby city where – during
apartheid – blacks performed the low-level jobs but only whites
The images of racial good will conveyed via the World Cup to a
global TV audience aren’t false. They embody the profound changes
that have transformed race relations in South Africa in the two
decades since apartheid began to dissolve.
But to declare South Africa a unified rainbow nation, as
President Jacob Zuma did last month, is premature. For a reporter
returning here for his first long visit since covering the
anti-apartheid unrest of 1987-90, the progress is striking – but so
too are the yawning divides that remain, the fears and resentments,
the lingering scars of the bad old days.
The progress and the long road ahead both become apparent in a
visit to the mostly white Boksburg district of Sunward Park, 20
minutes drive from Motholo’s hard-scrabble neighborhood.
There, Bernard Coetzee is the pastor at the local branch of the
Dutch Reformed Church – the largest denomination among the
Afrikaners who held political power during apartheid.
Many young Afrikaners feel comfortable under a black-led
government, says the 48-year-old Coetzee. ”But for my generation,
the change is more difficult than for them,” he said. ”We grew up
One of the toughest adjustments for his community, he said,
relates to affirmative action policies which give preference to
blacks, people of mixed race, and even white women over white
”They’re the last in the row now,” he said. ”That’s the most
Back in 1988, Boksburg made international news when right-wing
Afrikaners won control of the town council and voted to ban blacks
from public facilities that recently had been integrated –
including the town hall and a large lakeside park.
Now the park is a favorite leisure spot for blacks, and Boksburg
– along with many other nearby towns – is governed by a black-run
Mthuthuzeli Siboza, 49, serves on that council, representing
Vosloorus. He bemoans the township’s rampant unemployment and
HIV/AIDS epidemic, and gives mixed grades on race relations.
”Racism will remain with us forever,” he said. ”But you can
see people are forgetting about their negative tendencies and
uniting around soccer.”
At Coetzee’s Sunward Park Community Church, the congregation now
includes a few blacks, as does its day camp program, run by youth
pastor Gerrit Visser.
The 27-year-old Visser epitomizes the post-apartheid outlook of
many under-30 whites. Even though he once was carjacked by blacks
who threatened to kill him, he is upbeat about race relations and
South Africa’s future.
He told of a cousin who has moved to Britain and telephoned to
say that Visser should do likewise. ”I said to him, ‘You don’t
understand. I love these challenges,”’ Visser said. ”Stick here,
make a plan… We have every reason to be pessimistic, but we’re
Two years ago, Visser said, he and two friends flew to Uganda
and hitchhiked back home across southern Africa.
”Wherever we went, somehow the locals knew we were South
African,” he said proudly. ”They told us, ‘You walk like you’re
from around here.”’
Thato Motsepe, 22, an aspiring actress and recent graduate of
the University of Johannesburg, said the big divide in her
generation has more to do with education and ambition than skin
color. Describing herself as colorblind, she said interracial
dating is increasingly common, and more young whites are learning
Like other blacks her age, Motsepe venerates Nelson Mandela, the
longtime political prisoner elected in 1994 as the first
post-apartheid president. But she feels no compunction to view her
world through the prism of the anti-apartheid struggle.
”The older generation will always see color – it will remind
them of some kind of pain,” she said. ”It’s time we younger South
Africans stop imitating what they went through. It’s time to move
South Africans of Motsepe’s and Visser’s generation have only
fleeting memories, if any, of the full-fledged apartheid system
that prevailed from 1948 through the 1980s. Blacks had no vote in
national elections; residential areas, schools, hospitals, even
beaches were racially segregated.
For foreign journalists based here at the time, the system
produced jarring experiences – evading police barricades sealing
off volatile black townships, covering illegal protests, perhaps
even getting tear-gassed – then returning by evening to a placid,
Now, even affluent, mostly white neighborhoods are apt to
include some black homeowners, but there are relatively few areas
nationwide that are thoroughly mixed. Boksburg had one such suburb
in the 1990s, Dawn Park, but white flight has left it virtually all
As for the black townships, like Vosloorus, ”we don’t go
there,” Coetzee said.
Indeed, many of the hundreds of down-on-their-luck whites who’ve
set up squatter camps in recent years would have the option of
buying inexpensive new homes in the townships – but haven’t done
”Members of the black middle class have moved into traditional
white areas, but we don’t find a reciprocation,” said Eddie Makue,
general secretary of the South African Council of Churches.
”They’d rather eke out a living as squatters because of this
misperception that the townships are unsafe.”
Like many South Africans, Makue was pleasantly astounded when
thousands of Afrikaner rugby fans from Pretoria made their
first-ever visit to Soweto – and enjoyed themselves – for a match
in May that had been relocated to the huge black township because
of World Cup logistics.
”When white people do come into a black area, they are well
received,” Makue said. ”Many of those fans were absolutely
astonished they could go into a shebeen (pub) and not be
Kallie Kriel, head of an Afrikaner-rights lobbying group called
AfriForum, was among those at the rugby match.
He accuses the governing African National Congress of tolerating
some anti-white racism among its young leaders, but he feels race
relations at the grass-roots level are progressing well.
”It’s a relaxed atmosphere among normal people that’s being
endangered by the political elite,” he said. ”You don’t want that
to trickle down to ground level.”
The Soweto rugby match, and the heartwarming World Cup displays
of black-white unity, prompted John-Kane Berman, the head of the
South African Institute of Race Relations, to issue a status report
part way through the soccer tournament.
”Mixing across the color line in schools, universities,
hospital wards, and elsewhere, once forbidden by law, is growing,”
wrote Kane-Berman. ”This day-in, day-out mixing as part of normal
life has none of the symbolic significance of excited crowds in
football stadiums, but it is more important.”
But he said racial friction could worsen unless two dangers are
”One is that continuing corruption, crime and state failure …
will cause more and more whites to see failure in racial terms,”
he wrote. ”The other risk is that widening material inequality
will lead to growing racial tension for the obvious reason that so
much of the country’s private wealth remains in white hands.”
Indeed, the economic gap remains wide, with the average white
household’s income several times that of the average black
household. Yet affluence doesn’t guarantee peace of mind – as
reflected by the popularity of a book on emigration: ”Should I
Stay or Should I Go?”
For now, whites make up 9 percent of the population of 48
million, blacks about 80 percent.
In many white neighborhoods, the houses are sealed off by high
walls, often topped with metal spikes and electrified wire and
bearing the logos of armed-response security companies. In the
wealthier suburbs, odds are good that behind the walls is a
swimming pool and lush patio.
Some whites – and some blacks, as well – say one drawback of
their country is constant stress, worrying about crime. They may
get used to it, then notice it again with dismay when they return
after travel abroad.
Other grievances vary by neighborhood. While blacks in the
townships complain about inadequate housing and poor schools,
whites in the suburbs gripe about deteriorating public services –
trash collection, road maintenance.
One of the challenges – difficult in any nation – is for black
and white, rich and poor to try to see across the divide and find
some common bonds and understandings.
”At the human level, everybody wants to make it work – we’re
all a part of this fantastic, beautiful country,” said Sibongile
Mkhabela, who as a high school student was jailed for her role as a
leader of the 1976 Soweto uprising and is now CEO of the Nelson
Mandela Children’s Fund.
”Where the will falls off is when the self-interest comes in,”
Mkhabela said. ”What’s needed is for all of us to keep our eyes on
the bigger picture, to understand we might be inconvenienced, we
might feel discriminated against, but in the long term it’s in the
best interest of the country.”
Hard at work with her orphans in Vosloorus, Caroline Motholo
says she loves her job, yet describes it as a constant struggle –
scrounging for supplies, lobbying for funds, preaching safe sex to
a community not always eager for that message. Cartons of
government-supplied condoms are piled floor to ceiling in one of
the center’s rooms.
At 54, she’s old enough to have vivid memories of apartheid, and
overall is grateful for the changes since then. She views white
South Africans collectively as somewhat selfish, but says they have
no reason to be frightened.
”Nobody is going to hurt anybody,” she said. ”We can’t do
anything without the whites. They can’t do anything without the
Editor’s note: David Crary was the AP’s news editor in South
Africa from 1987-1990, during the climactic stages of the
anti-apartheid struggle. He returned for a five-week stint in
conjunction with the World Cup.
- A basis for harmony and diversity, together
- A return to the glory days of jazz with Jean Toussaint, plus the best jazz and folk gigs of 2018
- Jason Moran's Harlem Hellfighters salute James Reese Europe, plus the best jazz and folk gigs of 2018
- A 74-Year-Old Man Was Acquitted Of Assaulting A Far Right YouTuber Defending TV Host Sonia Kruger
- POLITICO London Playbook, presented by ExxonMobil: El veto bonito — 88 and counting — The job nobody wants
- We are all radically equal
- Doctor Who, Rosa, review: A thoughtful look at the civil rights movement
- Does Preston need an interfaith strategy?
- Mamallapuram Summit to set roadmap for India – China relations in the next decade
- The five things Neal Ardley must do now he is Notts manager
- 'Before our eyes, Italy is becoming a fascist state'
- Racist yob jailed after performing Nazi salute at antisemitism rally
- Hugo Duncan: The night Daniel O'Donnell's singing saved me from ire of hotel residents
- UK confirms reports of mass interment camps in China's Xinjiang
- Video installation puts Montreal Women's Symphony Orchestra in the spotlight
- Ince: Football cannot rest on its laurels when it comes to tackling racism
Racial harmony? Not yet, but SAfrica makes strides have 1959 words, post on www.foxsports.com at July 10, 2010. This is cached page on Asean News. If you want remove this page, please contact us.