By Coral Davenport and Lisa Friedman, New York Times
Published 8:40 pm, Saturday, April 7, 2018
Photo: TOM BRENNER, STF / NYT
WASHINGTON — As ethical questions threaten the Environmental Protection Agency administrator, Scott Pruitt, President Donald Trump has defended him with a persuasive conservative argument: Pruitt is doing a great job at what he was hired to do, roll back regulations.
But legal experts and White House officials say that in Pruitt’s haste to undo government rules and in his eagerness to hold high-profile political events promoting his agenda, he has often been less than rigorous in following important procedures, leading to poorly crafted legal efforts that risk being struck down in court.
The result, they say, is that the rollbacks, intended to fulfill one of the president’s central campaign pledges, may ultimately be undercut or reversed.
“In their rush to get things done, they’re failing to dot their i’s and cross their t’s. And they’re starting to stumble over a lot of trip wires,” said Richard Lazarus, a professor of environmental law at Harvard. “They’re producing a lot of short, poorly crafted rule-makings that are not likely to hold up in court.”
FOX 5’s Tom Fitzgerald reports.
Six of Pruitt’s efforts to delay or roll back Obama-era regulations — on issues including pesticides, lead paint and renewable-fuel requirements — have been struck down by the courts. Pruitt also backed down on a proposal to delay implementing smog regulations and another to withdraw a regulation on mercury pollution.
One of the chief examples cited by Pruitt’s critics came this week when the EPA filed its legal justification for what is arguably the largest rollback of an environmental rule in the Trump administration: the proposed undoing of an Obama-era regulation aimed at cutting pollution of planet-warming greenhouse gases from vehicle tailpipes.
Pruitt made his case for the rollback in a 38-page document filed Tuesday that, experts say, was devoid of the kind of supporting legal, scientific and technical data that courts have shown they expect to see when considering challenges to regulatory changes.
About half the document consists of quotations from automakers laying out their objections to the rule. By comparison, the Obama administration’s 1,217-page document justifying its implementation of the regulation included technical, scientific and economic analyses justifying the rule.
Environmental groups have welcomed Pruitt’s court losses. Joanne Spalding, chief climate counsel for the Sierra Club, said she was pleased by what she called “sloppy” and “careless” EPA legal work. “It’s fine with us,” she said. “Do a bad job repealing these things, because then we get to go to court and win.”
- China firms in $10 billion share sale rush as funding rules eased amid virus worries
- Full text: Barack Obama's Cairo speech
- EPA says it won’t cut biofuel quotas after corn states push back
- Trump taps Oklahoma attorney general, friend to fossil fuels, to run EPA
- EPA will regulate 'forever chemicals' in drinking water
- Moderate Democrats’ Delusions of ‘Prudence’ Will Kill Us All
- Sanders is a risk, not a winner
- Obama Announces Complete Withdrawal of U.S. Forces From Iraq by End of 2011
- Thirteen Americans evacuated from the Diamond Princess cruise at 'high risk' for coronavirus are being quarantined and treated for the infection - and one is in a Nebraska biocontainment unit
- The 13 Rules for Creating a Prestige TV Drama
- Did I Kill Gawker?
- Trump Administration to Reverse Offshore Oil Safety Rules Meant to Prevent Another Deepwater Horizon
- Budget WILL happen on March 11: New Chancellor Rishi Sunak rules out delaying crucial financial package in wake of Sajid Javid quitting - amid claims higher earners could be stripped of 40% pension tax relief
- Trump’s Nominee for U.N. Ambassador Kelly Craft Has Billion-Dollar Ties to Coal
- Yes, Democrats have to defend their African-American base against Trump
- Eichenwald: Kellyanne Conway Throws Gutter Ball, Massacres Facts
- ‘Endangers The Lives Of The Public’: Trump Goes On Rant About Los Angeles Mayor
- Alabama Senate Delays Vote On Abortion Bill After Lawmakers Start Screaming On Senate Floor
- Bloomberg’s ‘mercenaries’: Billionaire Dem funding network of climate lawyers inside state AG offices
- At least 33 US cities used water testing 'cheats' over lead concerns
Risks for EPA’s Pruitt in rush to kill Obama rules have 789 words, post on www.chron.com at April 6, 2018. This is cached page on Asean News. If you want remove this page, please contact us.