HONG KONG – The defence lawyer for the first person charged under Hong Kong’s national security law argued on Thursday (July 29) at a final mitigation session before sentencing that his client was a “decent young man” who did something very stupid.
Tong Ying-kit, 24, could be sentenced on Friday to several years to life imprisonment after being found guilty by a panel of three judges in the High Court for “terrorist activities” and “inciting secession” in a watershed ruling with long-term implications for the city’s judicial landscape.
Former waiter Tong, who lives with his father and younger sister in a public housing estate, was accused of driving his motorcycle into three riot police last year while carrying a flag with the protest slogan “Liberate Hong Kong. Revolution of our times.”
Judges Esther Toh, Anthea Pang and Wilson Chan – picked by city leader Carrie Lam to hear national security cases – ruled on Tuesday that this slogan was “capable of inciting others to commit secession”.
Clive Grossman, who was representing Tong, submitted that any incitement was only of a “minor nature” and none of the police officers were seriously injured, warranting a more lenient sentence.
He added that although Tong had ridden his motorbike recklessly that day, he was not engaging in a “deliberate attack to try to kill or injure the policemen” that his motorbike hit.
“He’s learnt a big lesson in prison… his life has been so badly affected. He’s essentially a decent young man who did something very stupid.” Grossman added that Tong had been supporting his father and sister financially, and that his grandmother, who has cancer, hoped to give him “one last hug”.
The prosecution lawyer, Ivan Cheung, submitted to the court a mainland Chinese legal textbook carrying commentaries on Chinese criminal law as a reference for the judges when considering a minimum sentence.
But justice Esther Toh told the court that such material is”not in any way binding” given established sentencing principles under Hong Kong’s Common Law and the national security law.
Cheung told reporters outside the court that the prosecution had “not consulted with any Chinese officials” in making their submission on proposed sentences for Tong.
Cheung declined to name the textbook but said it was similar to the mainland Chinese version of Hong Kong’s main reference book for criminal law, “Archbold Hong Kong”.
- China summons US envoy, asks Washington not to implement Hong Kong bill
- Hong Kong student protester, 18, who was shot in the chest by a cop with a live round appears in court to face charges of rioting and assaulting police
- Hong Kong gives protesters green light for big march on Sunday
- China hits NBA with broadcast blackout after Adam Silver discusses Hong Kong controversy
- Nikki Haley: Chinese attack on Hong Kong would pose grave danger to America’s Asian allies
- Here’s The Full Story Of How A University In Hong Kong Went To War With Police
- China suspends Hong Kong visits by U.S. military ships, aircraft, sanctions U.S. NGOs
- Trump meets with national security team on Afghanistan peace plan
- Sentencing Delayed In Michael Flynn Case After Judge Blasts Ex-National Security Adviser
- Fast track court set up to hear Hyderabad veterinarian's rape case
- Judge: NSA doesn’t have to keep all data as part of key surveillance lawsuit
- Transcript: David Rubenstein on "Face the Nation", December 1, 2019
- Federal judge disqualifies Huawei's lawyer
- Trump's week: from 'ordained by God' to dethroned by a judge
- Garry Kasparov: I lived in the post-truth Soviet world and I hear its echoes in Trump's America
- What to watch for at Wednesday's impeachment hearing
- Republicans launch disruption strategy to try to stop House Judiciary Committee's first impeachment hearing with repeated procedural interruptions - after chair Jerry Nadler says Donald Trump engaged in 'pattern of misconduct'
- Key witness in impeachment investigation asks federal judge to rule on testifying
- Trump Impeachment Hearing Live Updates: House Judiciary Committee Holds First Hearing After Damning Report
- President, lawyers should participate in impeachment hearing: Demings, McClintock
At hearing for Hong Kong national security case, judges hear defendant made 'stupid' mistake have 652 words, post on www.asiaone.com at July 29, 2021. This is cached page on Asean News. If you want remove this page, please contact us.